Writing

Writing · · 8 min read

People Are the Asset, Tools Are the Liability

Every world will bring new obstacles. It’s still ours to shape.

Super Mario jumping over a Hammer Bro
Choose a sticker to take it off. Arrow keys move between them.
Mario, jumping the next obstacle.You are here, under the weight of every new obstacle.

"Care is the missing craft."

A lone designer from 2026

In the late 1980s, I learned to draw on an Apple II, making shapes with Turtle Graphics in my elementary school’s computer lab. Twenty-five years into a design career, I’ve learned and let go of more tools than I can count. Not one of them is still in my workflow. What I learned while using them is that the tools change, but if you’re lucky, you change too. And if you’re really lucky, you change someone else.

It’s a bit like Super Mario. Every world throws something new at him: Goombas, Koopa Troopas, pipes, pits, a castle with a new boss at the end. The level changes. Power-ups help, but they don’t change how high Mario jumps. A running start does. Tools are the level. The designer is the player. Skills are like power-ups. The running start is yours: the momentum you build, and the timing only practice teaches.

Right now the world is in love with the idea of a machine holding those skills and power. But you are more powerful than you know.

That’s why this AI moment worries me. It speeds up the process, but it can slow down our collective creativity just as much. And it isn’t only about designers. Engineers have code generators, writers have language models, support teams have chatbots, and researchers are being offered synthetic users in place of real people. AI budgets keep growing while teams get smaller, and entry-level work is usually the first to go. Every company says its people are its greatest asset. Then budget season comes. Teams get trimmed. Licenses get renewed. It’s easy to treat a person as a cost and the newest tool as an investment. I think we have it all backwards.

The teammate is the asset. The tool is the liability: it depreciates, it needs maintenance, and eventually it gets replaced.

I’ve spent most of my career in design and accessibility. In human-centered work, the cost of skipping people shows up fast. When a team cuts the people whose job is to understand its customers, disabled people are often the first to be overlooked, as customers and as teammates. That’s the lens I’ll use here, but these levels are for every role.

Let’s start exploring your worlds, in a different way

World 1-1: The real power-up is shared practice

"A tool is only as good as the shared practice behind it."

Every tech worker, eventually

On paper, building a component library, a plugin, a design system, or a code assistant reads like a tool success story for many teams. But the tool is rarely the real product. The real product is a team’s shared language: people in every role agreeing on what things mean, and making those decisions together. A tool works because people keep shaping it. Someday it will be replaced by something newer. The shared language will outlast it, because it lives in people.

In 2019, a dozen designers, researchers and writers came together to form the Design for Inclusion Guild at the company I worked at. It was a group independent of team or discipline.

The group held a speaking series, workshops and initiatives to make our design system language and products more inclusive and accessible. The guild eventually wound down, but the people kept going. The shared language lived on in dozens of products and services that designers, researchers and writers led on their own. Yes, tools, libraries and systems came out of this work, including A11ykit, our accessibility annotation library for designers and developers. But it all started with a small group of people digging deeper into inclusive design than the company had asked them to.

That kind of work needs room to grow, and both leaders and individual contributors have to make that room. In 2020, the room got bigger. After the murder of George Floyd and the Black Lives Matter protests that followed, companies were being held accountable for their values, and many put real budgets behind diversity, equity and inclusion work. Then the room got smaller. Our focus shifted to A11ykit, and support for the guild faded. Across the industry, DEI budgets were often the first to go. The people who did the work didn’t disappear. Their practice is still in the products they shaped.

A 1985 Nintendo card: Mario leaps up brick steps as two Bullet Bills fly toward him, with mushrooms on the ledges above.
Choose your
Mario, running from automated workflows and career collapse.Choose your voice, over the world and the tools.

World 1-2: Every level needs a player who knows why

Even automation starts with people. A good tool can turn guidance into a guided workflow and make good practice easier. But someone had to understand that practice deeply enough to encode it, and someone has to keep it honest as standards and teams change.

Tools hold the instructions. People hold the why: the context, the tradeoffs, and the history of what was tried and didn’t work. The insight comes from people. The tools change because of it. New world, same player.

My accessibility team held the keys to the company’s entire accessibility workflow. More process would only have made us a bottleneck. Workflows hold the steps, but they can’t answer the question a team brings when the steps don’t fit. That’s where the why lives. So every Tuesday morning, at a time that worked across our partner teams’ time zones, we held office hours, and anyone could bring a question.

Slack and our calendar sent the reminders, but a teammate still ran it. They cancelled sessions by hand when no one had booked, shared what was coming up, and matched each question with the right person. You can automate a reminder. You can’t automate that kind of thoughtfulness.

It was one of my favorite parts of the week. Some questions got solved right on the call. Some people needed coaching on code, design or annotations. Others kicked off whole projects with us before moving into our A11y Review Workflow. Keeping it healthy took human care: open enough that anyone felt welcome, and clear enough that it never became a pile of unprioritized projects or unrealistic promises. The tools kept the schedule. People kept the why.

World 1-3: Hidden blocks only humans find

Some problems only show up when a person meets the product. Automation is built around the typical case, and it misses the people at the edges. Disabled people are the clearest example. A field can be technically labeled and still be confusing. A chart should never be the only way in. And no checker can replace someone telling you, in their own words, where a product let them down.

A designer and I knew our field selection feature relied on color alone to tell recipients apart. In a recent research session, a low-vision tester from Fable struggled to find a specific recipient’s fields and told us what that felt like. Then they did more than give feedback. They started designing ideas with us, right there on the call. That was the hidden block. Their words and ideas stayed with me, the part no tool could have found for us.

Clearer fields wouldn’t only help people with low vision. They’d help people with cognitive disabilities, neurodivergent people, and anyone who wants clarity in their tools. We always deserve clarity. Too often we get a blur instead, because someone didn’t care enough or didn’t know their own bias.

Test your work with real people. Sometimes a person can’t finish a critical task only because someone designed it in a way that left them out.

The warp zone: skipping the levels that teach you

Mario has warp zones: secret pipes that skip whole worlds. AI tools are a warp zone. They let people jump past work that used to take years, and sometimes that’s wonderful. But the early levels are where judgment gets built. The small, repetitive, beginner work is how most of us learned what good work is. If juniors never get to play World 1-1, who becomes the senior player later?

My early levels included an internship at Cisco Systems. I was the luckiest college kid in town, surrounded by people who cared enough to teach me. One of them had been a Disney animator, Paul. One day he walked over to my desk, looked at my notes, noticed how small my handwriting was, and said:

"If there’s one thing I’d recommend you work on, it’s your handwriting."

Paul, Disney Animator

It had nothing to do with the project in front of us. It was the kind of feedback that only comes from someone who’s been paying attention, and who speaks from experience and care. I spent years making my lettering clearer, bolder and more me. Thanks Paul.

I don’t think anyone would give that advice now. Not because it’s wrong, but because feedback mostly arrives through comments, emojis and AI suggestions. If we skip those early levels in our work, how do we create space for both learning and teaching each other?

It was oddly the one thing I needed. Confidence created by my own hands. Not a tool.

World 1-4: The castle needs players who teach

As tools get more automated, the risk isn’t too few tools. It’s plenty of tools and too few people who understand the process well enough to use them responsibly.

When beginner work disappears, the apprenticeship that came with it disappears too. Mentoring can’t be a side project anymore. Accessibility teams have always known this. We don’t just practice a craft. We teach it. Our real output is shared ownership: designers, product managers, content designers, engineers, and researchers all helping carry the work forward.

Teaching was a big part of my job. I coached people on A11ykit annotations, and more importantly on thinking critically about who a design might leave out. When I said goodbye to my team, I wrote, “I used to say that I was the only accessibility designer at the company. But you all are too.” Their replies said the rest.

“You made accessibility fun and so important for me!”

A designer

“I have learned a great deal and am a better designer because of you.”

Another designer

“Your kindness and inclusivity made a huge impact on me when I joined.”

A designer who had just joined the team

That’s the output no tool can ship. The world keeps racing ahead. I’m holding on to what the past taught me, and passing it on.

I hope the next world is brighter because of what the past taught us, and what you’ll teach next.

Dott

Game over? Continue.

Last week Lenny Rachitsky shared the state of the tech job market, and the headline for my field was hard to read: design is at a record low. There are about 1,900 open product design roles at tech companies worldwide, down 28% from a year ago. US companies hired less than half as many product designers this past year as they did in 2022. User research fell even further, down 66%.

Open design roles are at a record low

1,924 open product design roles at tech companies

Week of Oct 23, 2026

Data table (218 weeks)
Week ofOpen roles
Aug 26, 20224,824
Sep 2, 20224,766
Sep 9, 20224,664
Sep 16, 20224,587
Sep 23, 20224,516
Sep 30, 20224,395
Oct 7, 20224,194
Oct 14, 20224,028
Oct 21, 20223,881
Oct 28, 20223,724
Nov 4, 20223,514
Nov 11, 20223,355
Nov 18, 20223,239
Nov 25, 20223,163
Dec 2, 20223,085
Dec 9, 20222,995
Dec 16, 20222,847
Dec 23, 20222,708
Dec 30, 20222,604
Jan 6, 20232,573
Jan 13, 20232,538
Jan 20, 20232,477
Jan 27, 20232,417
Feb 3, 20232,364
Feb 10, 20232,319
Feb 17, 20232,272
Feb 24, 20232,216
Mar 3, 20232,147
Mar 10, 20232,099
Mar 17, 20232,128
Mar 24, 20232,079
Mar 31, 20232,039
Apr 7, 20232,066
Apr 14, 20232,057
Apr 21, 20232,030
Apr 28, 20232,048
May 5, 20232,018
May 12, 20231,990
May 19, 20232,007
May 26, 20232,026
Jun 2, 20232,027
Jun 9, 20232,027
Jun 16, 20232,046
Jun 23, 20232,014
Jun 30, 20232,003
Jul 7, 20231,999
Jul 14, 20232,020
Jul 21, 20232,038
Jul 28, 20232,007
Aug 4, 20232,039
Aug 11, 20232,070
Aug 18, 20232,093
Aug 25, 20232,065
Sep 1, 20232,058
Sep 8, 20232,058
Sep 15, 20232,035
Sep 22, 20232,029
Sep 29, 20232,035
Oct 6, 20232,026
Oct 13, 20232,048
Oct 20, 20232,067
Oct 27, 20232,048
Nov 3, 20232,024
Nov 10, 20232,027
Nov 17, 20231,993
Nov 24, 20232,001
Dec 1, 20231,978
Dec 8, 20231,968
Dec 15, 20231,960
Dec 22, 20231,960
Dec 29, 20231,957
Jan 5, 20241,960
Jan 12, 20241,992
Jan 19, 20242,093
Jan 26, 20242,153
Feb 2, 20242,147
Feb 9, 20242,114
Feb 16, 20242,123
Feb 23, 20242,082
Mar 1, 20242,138
Mar 8, 20242,170
Mar 15, 20242,173
Mar 22, 20242,223
Mar 29, 20242,267
Apr 5, 20242,257
Apr 12, 20242,249
Apr 19, 20242,274
Apr 26, 20242,278
May 3, 20242,248
May 10, 20242,320
May 17, 20242,375
May 24, 20242,386
May 31, 20242,403
Jun 7, 20242,389
Jun 14, 20242,409
Jun 21, 20242,451
Jun 28, 20242,491
Jul 5, 20242,433
Jul 12, 20242,390
Jul 19, 20242,419
Jul 26, 20242,381
Aug 2, 20242,339
Aug 9, 20242,305
Aug 16, 20242,297
Aug 23, 20242,359
Aug 30, 20242,421
Sep 6, 20242,447
Sep 13, 20242,444
Sep 20, 20242,452
Sep 27, 20242,473
Oct 4, 20242,485
Oct 11, 20242,499
Oct 18, 20242,505
Oct 25, 20242,527
Nov 1, 20242,505
Nov 8, 20242,478
Nov 15, 20242,450
Nov 22, 20242,428
Nov 29, 20242,410
Dec 6, 20242,404
Dec 13, 20242,368
Dec 20, 20242,349
Dec 27, 20242,318
Jan 3, 20252,292
Jan 10, 20252,323
Jan 17, 20252,394
Jan 24, 20252,459
Jan 31, 20252,502
Feb 7, 20252,537
Feb 14, 20252,551
Feb 21, 20252,517
Feb 28, 20252,557
Mar 7, 20252,574
Mar 14, 20252,595
Mar 21, 20252,597
Mar 28, 20252,622
Apr 4, 20252,600
Apr 11, 20252,597
Apr 18, 20252,591
Apr 25, 20252,557
May 2, 20252,524
May 9, 20252,510
May 16, 20252,494
May 23, 20252,486
May 30, 20252,486
Jun 6, 20252,490
Jun 13, 20252,473
Jun 20, 20252,449
Jun 27, 20252,451
Jul 4, 20252,438
Jul 11, 20252,444
Jul 18, 20252,467
Jul 25, 20252,440
Aug 1, 20252,399
Aug 8, 20252,371
Aug 15, 20252,346
Aug 22, 20252,320
Aug 29, 20252,359
Sep 5, 20252,429
Sep 12, 20252,501
Sep 19, 20252,550
Sep 26, 20252,583
Oct 3, 20252,628
Oct 10, 20252,637
Oct 17, 20252,608
Oct 24, 20252,554
Oct 31, 20252,632
Nov 7, 20252,615
Nov 14, 20252,591
Nov 21, 20252,535
Nov 28, 20252,498
Dec 5, 20252,472
Dec 12, 20252,431
Dec 19, 20252,383
Dec 26, 20252,327
Jan 2, 20262,292
Jan 9, 20262,358
Jan 16, 20262,426
Jan 23, 20262,483
Jan 30, 20262,534
Feb 6, 20262,590
Feb 13, 20262,634
Feb 20, 20262,696
Feb 27, 20262,771
Mar 6, 20262,838
Mar 13, 20262,860
Mar 20, 20262,780
Mar 27, 20262,693
Apr 3, 20262,627
Apr 10, 20262,571
Apr 17, 20262,508
Apr 24, 20262,444
May 1, 20262,365
May 8, 20262,303
May 15, 20262,266
May 22, 20262,245
May 29, 20262,215
Jun 5, 20262,168
Jun 12, 20262,115
Jun 19, 20262,077
Jun 26, 20262,036
Jul 3, 20262,015
Jul 10, 20261,982
Jul 17, 20261,979
Jul 24, 20261,966
Jul 31, 20261,960
Aug 7, 20261,960
Aug 14, 20261,960
Aug 21, 20261,965
Aug 28, 20261,960
Sep 4, 20261,960
Sep 11, 20261,960
Sep 18, 20261,964
Sep 25, 20261,960
Oct 2, 20261,964
Oct 9, 20261,975
Oct 16, 20261,960
Oct 23, 20261,924
Data: TrueUp, as charted in Lenny’s Newsletter. Weekly, August 2022 to October 2026. The line is traced from their chart. The two marked points are their exact numbers.

In the arcade, Game Over was never really the end. The screen asked “Continue?” and counted down from 9, and you had a few seconds to drop in another coin. Those numbers are the countdown. Here’s how I’d spend my coin.

  1. Move 1 of 3

    Teams are getting smaller. The need to work together isn’t.

    Find the people who care about what you care about, and work on it together. It can start with two of you.

    From World 1-1: a dozen people who cared built a shared language that outlasted their group.

  2. Move 2 of 3

    Tools need your steps to survive. People need you more.

    Give your steps to the tool if you have to. Give the why to a person, someone newer than you.

    From World 1-2: tools hold the instructions. People hold the why.

  3. Move 3 of 3

    Automation leaves people out. Talk to them to shape the work.

    Before you pick a tool, ask who it might leave out. Then find those people and bring them in early.

    From World 1-3: disabled people are the clearest example of who gets left out.

If you lead a team, invest in the players. Budget for learning, protect the beginner work that grows people, and ask who the work might leave out before you ask which tool to buy.

Those reports count jobs. They don’t count people. Plenty of us are scared right now, and that fear is easy to find. What nobody has measured yet is the rest of the feeling: how many of us are pushing back, and how many of us still have hope.

People count.
Let’s start counting.

Every coin has two sides. People have way more than two (we contain multitudes), but a coin is easier to flip. Heads is you. Tails is your work. Answer one side, or both.

PEOPLE ARE THE ASSET ✶ HEADS ✶ PEOPLE ARE THE ASSET ✶ HEADS ✶
Your coin: a blank face, waiting for a feeling.

Heads:how does this moment feel for you?

Tails:which part of your work should no tool ever do for you?

Care is the craft. Invest in the people who practice it, and the people who teach it.

This could be your voice

Give this a heart

Counting…

Reader highlights

Select a line you like and choose Highlight.

    Share this post

    Know someone who could use a running start? Pass it on.

    dottdotter.com/peoplepower